Lena's Pizza, Subs & Wings in Fredonia, NY, has established itself as the quintessential pizza destination, and customer reviews say it all. Patrons rave about their extra-large pizzas and bucket of wings, with one delighted customer, Dolores Case, declaring her order the best she’s ever had—perfectly cooked and right on time. Another frequent visitor, Windows McAfee, highlights the restaurant's consistency over the last two decades, adding that the current ownership has maintained the same high quality that has earned Lena's a loyal following.
Despite some issues with phone accessibility, as noted by sam eberle, customers overwhelmingly favor Lena’s for its exceptional wings and rich blue cheese. Former local Paul March reminisces about his wife’s childhood favorites, praising the restaurant for its amazing crust and generous toppings, all cooked to perfection. For travelers, like Travelling Tumbleweed, Lena’s is a must-stop culinary experience, building a reputation that reaches far beyond New York State. In summary, Lena's Pizza, Subs & Wings is not just a meal; it's a delightful journey into pizza perfection.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has outdoor seating
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves vegetarian dishes
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Family friendly
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Photos
Reviews For Lena's Pizza, Subs & Wings - Fredonia NY
Dolores Case
Jun 29,2025
Ordered pizza and wings to be ready for 7:30 pm. Pick up because delivery wasn’t available. Got ex large pizza and bucket of wings! This order was the best we ever had. It was outstanding!! Cooked to perfection! Ready on time! Can’t say enough about Lena’s in Fredonia!!
Windows McAfee
Jun 27,2025
Best and most consistent pizza place in Fredonia. Owned by a former employee, the place hasn't changed in quality for at least 20 years. Good staff, great website and advanced phone service. If you don't believe me you can watch an Episode on "Small Business Revolution" all about them. Easily my go-to pizza place around town. I've never had a bad pie from them... Ever.
sam eberle
Jun 18,2025
Honestly the best wings and blue cheese in the area. Only complaint is that the Fredonia location sometimes just doesn’t answer their phone. It just rang (replaying the same message) for about 10 minutes straight. Tried that twice before switching to a competitor. That’s the third time that’s happened! I’ll still choose them over the competition, as long as they answer the phone! lol.
Paul March
May 5,2025
We were in town for a visit and my wife knew they were good many years ago when she was growing up here. I can say they are still hitting the ball out of the park, amazing crust and generous toppings, all cooked to perfection. This will be a go to on all future visits!
Travelling Tumbleweed
Apr 27,2025
Truly delicious! Stopped here for a quick slice on our way back to Canada. The young man was shocked I said heyyy we heard about you and we drove from Toronto! No...but I will be back and Lena’s will be my first stop!
Joseph Medicis
Apr 6,2025
Had a good time as far as I can remember! My buddy and I wandered in quite intoxicated looking for a pizza at like 1am and they graciously made us both personal pizzas. I made sure to tip (money is fake! Haha) and in my drunken state I thoroughly enjoyed my pizza. I'm sure it's quite amazing sober too, I highly recommend this place if you're in need of some midnight munchies. They were patient with us and weren't mean despite us probably annoying them. I appreciate things like that very much.
Matthew Vercant
Mar 19,2025
Good years ago, great now. What is it about pepperoni and banana peppers that Lena's gets right, when so many get it wrong? Is it my sense of nostalgia? No. But it *is* that the toppings are generous enough in distribution to taste them in every bite.
Reviews For Lena's Pizza, Subs & Wings - Fredonia NY